Goodreid Blog

The Demise Of SVB

March 15, 2023

Banks are only viable institutions with the trust of their customers. Banks rely on deposits to fund much of their business activity, such as commercial loans, mortgages and other debt offerings. Because they are vital to the economy, governments oversee and regulate banks rigorously. However, in this age of digital access, the concept of “a run on the bank” is quite different than it was 90 years ago at the start of the Great Depression, when as old photos illustrate, long lines of people formed to wait their turn to withdraw their money. Today, instant access allows depositors to withdraw funds anywhere, anytime. As we witnessed last weekend that changes things. Even with enhanced regulations, rigorous stress tests and reporting transparency, liquidity risks have risen. Without due recognition, the actions of the U.S. Treasury last weekend to de-facto guarantee deposits have changed the landscape dramatically.

Banking in the U.S. is quite different than in Canada. For starters, there are close to 5000 banks in the U.S. compared to just 34 in Canada. Many U.S. banks are quite small, serving niche markets, from both a focus standpoint and geographically. Such is the case of SVB, a bank with a largely one-dimensional funding source, tech companies and tech start-ups.     

A brief explanation of what happened to SVB is in order. The history of Central Bank action is that inevitably something will break. Raising interest rates as aggressively as the Fed has done has left many portfolios with unrealized losses in their Fixed Income portfolios. This includes individual accounts, banks, insurance companies and government balance sheets. If these entities have enough in reserve the losses do not need to be realized. The embedded unrealized loss simply slowly bleeds out through opportunity cost until the maturity of the underperforming bond. At that point it pays 100 cents on the dollar. In the case of SVB, the bank did not have sufficient reserves to pay fleeing depositors, forcing them to sell bonds at losses. This forced them to raise additional capital, setting off alarm bells and a fear of a credit downgrade, leading to a “run on the bank”. Exacerbating the problem, SVB’s management increased risk by allowing an asset/liability mismatch; (ie. bonds with longer duration suffering financially as rates rise (bank asset), vs. short term rates on deposits becoming more costly as rates rise (bank liability)).

Conclusion: A perfect storm for SVB but very unlikely to be a contagion event, in fact owning bank stocks may be safer than ever.

Gordon Reid

President & CEO

Gordon Reid, President and CEO of Goodreid Investment Counsel Corp., entered the financial services business in 1985 and co-founded Goodreid Investment Strategy, one of Canada's first fully discretionary "high net worth" wrap accounts.

See Biography

Other Posts

The Financial Post: These tax-loss selling targets are also table-pounding buys

23 November, 2023

As we approach year-end, many investors are turning their attention to tax-loss selling, the strategy of selling investments that have experienced a loss in order to offset capital gains and potentially reduce an investor’s tax liability.

Read More

The Financial Post: Banks are taking it on the chin, but here’s why they deserve a second look

26 October, 2023

Canadian banks have long been considered a solid investment choice for a variety of reasons, but perhaps the best thing they have going for them is the oligopolistic nature of the industry. The Big Six — namely Royal Bank of Canada, Toronto-Dominion Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia, Bank…

Read More

The Financial Post: Just as in baseball, investors can do better by waiting for the perfect pitch

28 September, 2023

Major League Baseball playoffs have arrived, and the best teams will duel it out to be crowned world champions for another year. While history will undoubtedly be made, with exciting walk-offs and bitter disappointments on tap, one thing is and has always been true: hitting a baseball…

Read More

The Globe and Mail: Dividend investing works wonders - and now’s a great time to start with these three stocks

29 August, 2023

When it comes to investing in a diversified portfolio of Canadian equities, there are usually two choices: a total return Canadian equity portfolio, or a Canadian equity dividend portfolio that generates considerably higher income.

Read More

The Globe and Mail: Why this money manager thinks Canada is the best place to invest over the U.S. right now

12 May, 2023

While many investors look around the world for the best places to invest, money manager Robert Gill believes some of the best bets are at home in Canada, especially now. Mr. Gill, senior vice president and Canadian portfolio manager at Goodreid Investment Counsel Corp. in Toronto,…

Read More

The Globe and Mail: What is Topicus and why it’s a stock pick among our Investing Club members

03 May, 2023

Years ago I was fortunate enough to be invited to Omaha, Neb., to have lunch with Warren Buffett. As Warren sat down beside me at Gorat’s, his favourite steakhouse, I was bursting with questions. After a brief introduction, I asked, “What advice would you offer a young person starting…

Read More