Goodreid Blog

Banks & Mortgage Stress Tests: Fuelling The Fire

February 19, 2020

This week, the federal government announced that it is changing the stress test rate for insured mortgages starting April 6th.  Good news for the banks.  Bad news for aspiring home buyers.  The government will no doubt spin this as a victory for aspiring young homebuyers, but it’s not.  The looser credit will simply fuel more rapid gains in prices, leading to more debt accumulation and debt servicing costs and transferring wealth to existing homeowners via price appreciation.

From the banks’ standpoint, this easing of the regulatory lending guidelines will allow for mortgage loan growth to continue the acceleration it’s been on at the big 6 banks for the last three quarters after very tepid loan growth over the preceding two years amidst the B-20 guidelines, the various empty home taxes, the foreign buyer taxes, tightening the CRA rules for reporting capital gains, etc.  The tighter lending criterion has had the unintended consequence of bleeding off loan demand from the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions regulated banks in favour of lenders in the unregulated shadow banking sector, which very likely made the financial system LESS resilient to a potential housing price correction, not MORE resilient, as was intended.

Banks have been lagging the TSX overall since March 2018, which in the absence of recession is an unusually long period of underperformance from this secularly outperforming industry, although the magnitude of underperformance has been shallow at just 11.4%. 

At Goodreid, we think this might be the thrust the banks need to regain their relative performance vs. the overall market.  


For more background on this story:

Gordon Reid

President & CEO

Gordon Reid, President and CEO of Goodreid Investment Counsel Corp., entered the financial services business in 1985 and co-founded Goodreid Investment Strategy, one of Canada's first fully discretionary "high net worth" wrap accounts.

See Biography

Other Posts

Are Stocks Expensive?

18 August, 2020

A common assertion made by investors these days, both novices and pros alike, is that stocks are expensive after the fastest and sharpest recovery from a bear market in modern history.

Read More

Trust The Math

12 February, 2016

Market corrections are uncomfortable. Investors’ emotional responses are rooted in the worry that a catastrophe will occur.

Read More

In Defence Of Active Management

18 August, 2016

On August 4th, the Globe and Mail reported that just 17% of large-capitalization equity fund managers in Canada outperformed their benchmark in the second quarter, which proved to be the worst quarter for active managers in at least 17 years.

Read More

Investing, Not Gambling

03 September, 2014

It seems that every time I look at the Business section of a newspaper or tune into a Business channel someone is asking whether we should “take some off the table”. This bugs me on a couple of levels.

Read More

Goodreid Turns 30

26 September, 2016

Today marks the thirtieth anniversary of an investment approach developed to aid investors who were searching for a path to long-term wealth creation.

Read More

What We Learned from Canadian Banks Q1 2019 Earnings

05 March, 2019

Canadian banks are important…not just to Goodreid’s clients (although they are very important to us, comprising nearly 20% of our Canadian portfolio), but to the overall direction of the S&P TSX Composite Index...

Read More